What to Expect From Travis Bergen

Toronto Blue Jays on Twitter: "ROSTER MOVES: Rule 5 selection ...
Twitter photo

I have to be honest: not much.

The lefty reliever was added to the 40-man and promoted from Rochester, home of the Alternatives, just in time to likely face a Tampa lineup that will have six left-handed hitters in the lineup.

I was a big Bergen booster back in the day, and watched patiently as injuries limited him to only ten innings over his first two pro seasons. The organization overhauled his delivery during that time, putting him on a more forward path to the plate, and when he was healthy, it paid off: Bergen was lights out in the back of a pair of championship bullpens – Vancouver in 2017, and New Hampshire the following season.

Many eyebrows were raised when he has left exposed to the Rule 5 draft in 2018 after that winning season with the Fisher Cats. Bergen was scooped up by the Giants, but was returned to Toronto late in the 2019 season.

Bergen does not fit the profile of a power arm. His fastball “only” sits in the low 90s; he relies on pitchability, and control of his high 70s curve and tumbling, mid-80s change. Before MLB rules changes came along, he did profile as a LOOGY, but his value has diminished with the three batter minimum.

This is a guy who knows as much as pitching and how to pitch as anyone in the organization. But there isn’t enough of a differential between his fastball and off speed pitches to make him much more of a journeyman in today’s game. In another era, he probably would be a very successful middle relief guy. But with today’s starters relying more on their breaking balls, teams want arms coming in from the bullpen to throw cheese to give hitters a different look late in games.

I could be wrong, but I don’t anticipate Bergen sticking with the big club for long. In the past two seasons, he has climbed a huge mountain – left off the 40, claimed by another team, returned to the organization, and scrapped his way back to the 40. That’s not to be overlooked, and says a lot about Bergen’s resilience. And the value of left-handed pitching.

2 thoughts on “What to Expect From Travis Bergen

  1. Hey, had a question about a couple of current Jays: Grichuk & Teoscar H. Both are available to me in a Strat-o-matic baseball league. If you aren’t familiar with it, a player’s defense is important, as well as his OBP and speed. Looking at the next two years or so, who do you see having the higher floor/ceiling, and most playing time? Right now, I imagine I’d have to platoon Grichuk against lefties only, and then find a defensive home (DH?) for TH. Appreciate your insights.


    1. I haven’t played it in years (the ’86 season is upstairs in a box), but I love Strat! I grew up on it. When I think of great players, I tend to think in terms of their best season on a Strat card. Joe Morgan’s 1976 card stands out in particular.
      Your question is a good one. Both have had strong seasons to date (small sample size alert). I think if you’re after the safer bet, it might be Grich. But Hernandez has such tremendous upside. Both come with risks. Hope this helps.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.